Disadvantages of a Water Tube Boiler - Must be more careful of feed-water quality - More complex control systems for drum level necessary due to smaller water spaces, (although I have worked in ...
The design of water tube boilers is strictly opposite to that of fire tube boilers design. In water tube boiler systems, the water to be heated is enclosed inside the boiler tubes whereas the hot combustion gases exhausted by the burner keep circulating around the tube surfaces.
Boiler Types: Advantages and Disadvantages By: Dane Haystead Objective: To inform the public about the pros and cons of different types of boilers. Types of Boilers Shell boilers Water-tube boilers Shell Boilers Advantages: Able to purchase whole plant as package.
The boiler in which the water is present inside the tubes and fire or hot gases surrounds these fire tubes. The examples of water tube boilers are a La-Mont boiler, Benson boiler, Stirling boiler, Babcock and Wilcox boiler, Yarrow boiler and Loeffler boiler.
Fire tube boiler is easy to use, clean and maintain. It can be easily used in small scale industries. Fire tube boiler is relatively cheaper than water tube boiler. Disadvantages of Fire Tube Boiler: Steam output pressure cannot be very high since the water and steam are enclosed in the same vessel
Advantages and Disadvantages of Water Tube Boilers over Fire Tube Boilers: Advantages: 1. Steam can be raised more quickly: In water tube boilers, the ratio of water content to the steam capacity is comparatively less than the fire tube boiler.
Advantages of water tube boilers. The advantages of water tube boilers are as follows. Large heating surface can be obtained using a large number of smaller tubes because of which steam can be produced rapidly. Also the steam quality will be better than that of fire tube boilers.
Disadvantages of water tube boilers. Unlike fire tube boilers, most of the water tube boiler systems can not be manufactured in packaged form. Hence, their installation procedure at the job site tends to be comparatively difficult and time consuming. The installation and initial cost of these boiler systems happens to be very high.
Disadvantages of Water Tube Boiler: Water Tube Damage: Boiler Tube can be damaged if there is any dust in the feed water. Because it blocks the water circulation. Deposition of salt and sediments in the inner surface of Water Tube is a common problem for this type of boiler. Water Level: Water Tube Boiler use less water and for this reason, the ...
What are the advantages and disadvantages of a water tube boiler? Update Cancel. ... Between fire tube and water tube boilers, which has more advantages and why?